We continue with criticism of the sixth volume of the Library of Scarpa. I say again that the reviews of volumes may not be made in order. The story scores are now given Gathered in the end together with an average 🙂
Stories
McDuck Foundation: I found this story very good. I liked it designally, but the coloring on the pages wasn't that good. It was irritating to see one Scrooge with colored sideburns and the other normally. Scrooge's encounter with Chrysocheri has its phases. But the script is done beyond and beyond. predictable With the frames that have the two meeting in secret. So the end isn't surprising and that for me makes history lose points. Scrooge is quite a Barksico.
The School of Destruction: Here we have Martina in the script so we expect a little more extreme things. Okay, I think he's pulling from the hair that Donald's not educated or generally being too clumsy. Even though I laughed at the whole school thing and the chase in the end like a story didn't drive me crazy. I didn't remember it, but slowly with her reading, I remembered that I had read it once in the classics and then I was impressed with the same things. I don't have anything to say. Very good, only with the Marrows falling a little short not only in the plan but also in number. 😛 Really, why not three and he has two?
The Man from Ulla-Ula: Interesting the way the story unfolds with the stories of ducks. Everyone gives a piece of the story that says the meeting with Bongo took place and is part of the story. Nice gang and I liked the twist with the Marrows in the end (why only two again? 😛 It wasn't a diamond, but very good. 🙂
Total
Balanced volume. It does not distinguish a story to a large extent from the others. The best I'd say is The Man from Ulla-Ula. Personally, the drafts didn't hurt me but it was good to have them to see what the story was like but on the other hand they're in Italian and they're getting free space while a story could have been put in place.
1 Comment
Themistoklis Eleftheriadis
8 December 2017Δεν μου αρεσε καμία ιστορία του τομου. Ούτε στο Κομιξ που τις εκθειαζε. Με διαφορά ο χειροτερος τόμος. Ας πουμε, είναι δυνατον να υπάρχει διχτυ που να σηκώνει τόνους νομισματα, και τα λεφτά να λείπουν απο κατω, και να υπάρχει το απολυτο κενό ;