We continue with criticism of this year's ninth volume Library of Scarpa. The story scores are now given Gathered in the end together with an average 🙂
Stories
The Emperor of Calisota: History I'd read before in classics and somehow forgot about it. I liked the whole Western and mystery perfume he tried to create. In general I also like stories that have references to the city of heroes in the past. This is where we learned his name. Mickey City before it became a modern city. Beep Beep fits the story well and gives solutions wherever he has to. Still, Mickey's plan and the plot twists were pretty good. Of course, while the end is trying to be humorous, it's kind of exaggerated. The plan is great.
The Kidnapping of Jenny: Good story and here we see the first appearance of Luli Lulaki. Strange not to see him with her. Jenny. Like the newest stories. Nice plan, though Jenny seemed a little older than I'm used to it. Smart Scrooge He managed to trick him. Luli.
The Legendary Kingdom of Shangri La: The best story in the volume for me. That's a good plan and finally the Beep Beep It's the right color! On the side of the script I like it but I can't help but say that the author's character seemed completely useless to me and could in his place be Goofy. How much I enjoyed seeing Trudy to make salt Pete. It's not called. Some gang was really nice. Well, considering the cartoons, Pete's flirting made sense. But let me say that the end that reminded me of the end of stories like The Seven Cities of Cibola I didn't like it, but I'd like it to end somehow differently. Finally, I'll say that the comparison with Barks' story, Tralla la It's inevitable. Yeah, well, I like Barks' story a lot more than I like Scarpa's.
Total
Very nice and this volume with very good stories that keep you. I love his work. Scarpa Mickey. Righteous is considered a continuation of Gottfredson. But about the previous volume he is weaker, but that does not mean that he is not good.
3 Comments
Themistoklis Eleftheriadis
1 August 2018Νομίζω η κριτική σου ήταν λίγο πρόχειρη. Δεν εμβαθύνει στα νοήματα.Συμφωνώ με τις βαθμολογίες για τις ιστορίες με τον Μίκυ, που διάβασα. Δεν συμφωνώ για την βαθμολογία του Τόμου. Δεν αξίζει πάνω από 6 , αφού ο χρωματισμός είναι άθλιος, τα εισαγωγικά είναι σπόϊλερ, και αναφέρονται μόνο στις πρώτες εκδόσεις στην Ιταλία και όχι στην Ελλάδα. Άρα λοιπόν έχουμε ακριβά υλικά, αλλά το φαγητό είναι μέτριο… Α, και τα μπαλονάκια υπερφορτωμένα, μακρυά από τους διαλόγους της ά έκδοσης, γεμάτα αφόρητους βερμπαλισμούς.
ΚΟΜΙΞ
1 August 2018Δεν το έχω πει αλλά δεν συμπεριλαμβάνω το χρωματισμό διότι είμαι κάπως πιο χαλαρός στο θέμα αυτό καθώς παίρνουν ακριβώς ότι έχει η Ιταλική έκδοση. Οπότε δύσκολα θα τον συμπεριλάβω. Παρόλα αυτά ο επόμενος τόμος έχει όντως κακό χρωματισμό και δύσκολα αυτή τη φορά να μην το πάρω υπόψιν. Θα το αναφέρω εκτενέστατα. Εδώ όχι. Και κρίνω αυστηρό το 6 έστω και για το χρωματισμό.
Themistoklis Eleftheriadis
1 August 2018Αξίζει νομίζω ν’ αναφέρουμε ότι η Σάνγκρι-Λα είχε και remake, με τίτλο Ο Τύραννος του Βορρά. Ωστόσο δεν έφτασε στα επίπεδα της πρωτότυπης ιστορίας.